In May, of 1966, the body of nine-year old Amy Lewis was found floating in Cripple Creek, outside of Rural Retreat, Virginia. The autopsy revealed severe head trauma caused by a blunt object, probably a rock, along with numerous scratches and cuts on her body. The young girl had put up a fierce struggle against her attacker, who undoubtedly was surprised by the slightly built child’s ferocity. Blood and skin samples were found underneath her nails, and droplets of blood and strands of hair were scattered along the banks of the creek. Investigators surmised that Amy Lewis’ killer was physically unimposing and lacked physical strength, which pointed to the possibility that the murderer might be another child.
At the time of Amy Lewis’ murder, Alice lived twenty miles away in Maple Grove, which on the surface would have excluded her as a suspect because of the distance involved. Alice was also not known for being physically active and loathed childhood activities like exploring the outdoors.
There was one person, however, who thought Alice was the perfect suspect.
Doane Hassey was sixteen-years old at the time of Amy Lewis’ murder, and was having issues of his own, particularly with his parents, who worried that their younger son was on the fast track to becoming a criminal. It was no secret that Doane was a suspect in several residential break-in’s around the county, and was known for being reckless to the point of being dangerous. Local law enforcement had a particular hard-on for Doane because of his “fuck you” attitude and disregard for authority. Doane was a lot of things in the sixties, but he wasn’t without a conscience, which kicked in a month after Amy Lewis was murdered.
On the day Amy Lewis’ body was found, which was on a Saturday, Alice’s parents had gone to Roanoke to visit friends, and wouldn’t be back until Sunday. Doane’s friend’s had picked him up that morning to go to Bristol, which left Alice home alone–with a car. Gil, who was in the military at the time, had left his 1960 Ford Falcon at home, which his father had promised to keep up. Alice wasn’t old enough to drive, but that wouldn’t have stopped her from her compulsion to kill, and when Doane recalled the incident at Hooper’s Mill, three years earlier, he told his parents what he thought. Unfortunately, Doane’s lousy reputation along with his parents indignation that he would even suggest something that horrible led to a family fight, which caused Doane to runaway–and Alice to do what she pleased.
Like kill.